240 Would You Rather Questions for Kids of ALL Ages: Hilarious & Thought-Provoking

Jump to:

Let’s face it, keeping kids entertained can be tougher than a three-legged race in quicksand. But fear not, caregivers and teachers! “Would You Rather…?” is a classic game as simple as it is engaging. It’s not just a fun way to pass the time on family game night or a road trip – it’s a sneaky way to boost those little brains. This article is your one-stop shop for a mountain of “Would You Rather…?” questions for children of all ages, from preschoolers to teenagers. Get ready to spark some hilarious debates, ignite imaginations, and maybe even learn a thing or two about what makes those young minds tick. Because “Would You Rather…?” isn’t just about silly choices – it’s about developing critical thinking, communication skills, and having good old-fashioned fun. Explore questions covering a range of topics from silly scenarios to thought-provoking dilemmas, perfect for any occasion.

Table of Contents

A. Would You Rather Questions for Preschoolers (Ages 3-5)

Engaging preschoolers in playful learning is crucial for their early childhood development. “Would you rather…” questions offer a fun and effective way to stimulate their cognitive skills, language development, and social-emotional growth. These simple questions present concrete choices within relatable scenarios, fostering imagination, decision-making, and communication. Here are sixty examples to spark their curiosity:

Playtime & Activities – focusing on Gross Motor Skills, Fine Motor Skills, and Creative Play

Would you rather… play in the sandbox or swing on the swings?
Would you rather… slide down a big slide or a small slide?
Would you rather… build a tower with blocks or draw a colorful picture?
Would you rather… sing a song with your friends or listen to a story?
Would you rather… play hide-and-seek or tag?
Would you rather… play with playdough or finger paint?
Would you rather… build a fort or have a tea party?
Would you rather… dress up as a superhero or a princess?
Would you rather… play with bubbles or a ball?
Would you rather… read a book or tell a story?
Would you rather… dance to music or play a musical instrument (like a toy drum or xylophone)?
Would you rather… go to the playground or the library?

Food & Treats – focusing on Tastes, Textures, and Healthy Choices

Would you rather… eat a cookie or an apple?
Would you rather… drink juice or milk?
Would you rather… have a piece of candy or a fruit snack?
Would you rather… eat a sandwich or soup?
Would you rather… have ice cream in a cone or a bowl?
Would you rather… eat pancakes or waffles?
Would you rather… eat French fries or mashed potatoes?
Would you rather… drink chocolate milk or strawberry milk?
Would you rather… eat grapes or berries?
Would you rather… eat a popsicle or an ice cream sandwich?
Would you rather… eat pizza or chicken nuggets?
Would you rather… drink water or lemonade?

Animals & Toys – Expanding on Animal Types and Play Preferences

Would you rather… have a teddy bear or a puppy?
Would you rather… play with a toy car or a doll?
Would you rather… pet a cat or a dog?
Would you rather… see a lion at the zoo or a monkey?
Would you rather… ride a horse or a bike?
Would you rather… have a pet goldfish or a hamster?
Would you rather… play with a stuffed animal or an action figure?
Would you rather… have a toy train set or a race car track?
Would you rather… play with building blocks or a puzzle?
Would you rather… draw with crayons or colored pencils?
Would you rather… play with a dollhouse or a toy farm?
Would you rather… have a pretend picnic or a tea party?

Colors & Clothing – Exploring Sensory Details and Personal Style

Would you rather… wear a red shirt or a blue shirt?
Would you rather… wear pants or a skirt/dress?
Would you rather… wear sandals or sneakers?
Would you rather… have a yellow hat or a green hat?
Would you rather… wear a raincoat or a snowsuit?
Would you rather… wear something soft or something scratchy?
Would you rather… wear pajamas all day or a fancy outfit?
Would you rather… wear bright colors or dark colors?
Would you rather… wear stripes or polka dots?
Would you rather… wear a costume or your regular clothes?
Would you rather… have a lot of different clothes or just a few favorite outfits?
Would you rather… choose your own clothes or have someone else choose them for you?

Everyday Choices – Focusing on Routines, Preferences, and Social-Emotional Learning

Would you rather… take a bath or a shower?
Would you rather… go to bed early or stay up late?
Would you rather… play inside or play outside?
Would you rather… have a birthday party or a picnic?
Would you rather… give a hug or get a hug?
Would you rather… help with chores or play with your toys?
Would you rather… go to school or stay home?
Would you rather… eat breakfast or dinner?
Would you rather… brush your teeth or comb your hair?
Would you rather… read a book before bed or have someone tell you a story?
Would you rather… go to the doctor or the dentist? (Hopefully neither!)
Would you rather… share your toys or keep them all to yourself?

Remember to keep the tone light and playful. Encourage preschoolers to explain their choices, which helps develop their language, reasoning skills, and emotional intelligence. These questions offer a fun and engaging way to interact with young children while fostering their cognitive development and social skills.

B. Would You Rather Questions for Elementary Schoolers (Ages 6-10)

Elementary school is a time of boundless imagination, burgeoning independence, and developing social skills. “Would you rather…” questions are a fantastic way to tap into this creativity, sparking fun discussions and helping kids explore their values and preferences in a playful way. Here are sixty engaging scenarios designed for this age group, covering a range of themes and encouraging critical thinking and problem-solving:

Adventures & Fantastical Situations:

Would you rather… have the ability to fly or become invisible?
Would you rather… have a pet dragon or a pet unicorn?
Would you rather… live in a treehouse or a castle?
Would you rather… explore a magical forest or travel to outer space?
Would you rather… meet a superhero or a friendly alien?
Would you rather… have a magic wand or a time machine?
Would you rather… be able to talk to animals or understand any language?
Would you rather… live in a world made of candy or a world made of LEGOs?
Would you rather… be a pirate or a knight?
Would you rather… explore the ocean depths in a submarine or fly to the moon in a rocket ship?
Would you rather… have a superpower of your choice or a magical pet that helps you?
Would you rather… go on a quest to find a hidden treasure or solve a mystery in a haunted house?

Silly & Giggle-Inducing Choices:

Would you rather… have spaghetti for hair or mashed potatoes for hands?
Would you rather… speak only in rhymes or only in backwards words?
Would you rather… turn into a frog or a bumblebee?
Would you rather… have to sing everything you say or dance everywhere you go?
Would you rather… smell like a skunk or a dirty sock?
Would you rather… have a nose that honks like a clown horn or ears that wiggle like a bunny?
Would you rather… only be able to laugh or only be able to cry?
Would you rather… have hiccups for a day or have your shoes stuck to the floor?
Would you rather… wear a clown costume to school or wear your pajamas inside out?
Would you rather… turn into a cartoon character for a day or have your favorite cartoon character come to life?
Would you rather… eat a bug or lick a slug?
Would you rather… have a giant pet ant or a tiny pet elephant?

Food & Fun:

Would you rather… eat pizza every day or ice cream every day?
Would you rather… have a birthday party every month or Christmas every day?
Would you rather… eat only vegetables or only candy?
Would you rather… have a food fight with your friends or a giant water balloon fight?
Would you rather… cook dinner for your family or clean up the dishes?
Would you rather… eat a giant cookie or a whole cake?
Would you rather… drink a milkshake or a smoothie?
Would you rather… eat popcorn at the movies or candy?
Would you rather… have a picnic in the park or a barbecue in your backyard?
Would you rather… eat breakfast for dinner or dinner for breakfast?
Would you rather… try a new food every day or eat your favorite foods all the time?
Would you rather… bake cookies or decorate a cake?

School & Learning – Focusing on Academic Preferences, Skills, and School Experiences:

Would you rather… go to school in a spaceship or a submarine?
Would you rather… have a robot teacher or a superhero teacher?
Would you rather… never have homework or get paid to do your homework?
Would you rather… be the smartest kid in class or the funniest?
Would you rather… have recess all day or a field trip every week?
Would you rather… be really good at reading or really good at math?
Would you rather… be able to draw anything perfectly or play any musical instrument like a pro?
Would you rather… have all A’s in school or be the most popular kid in school?
Would you rather… learn a new language or learn how to code?
Would you rather… go to a school with uniforms or a school where you can wear whatever you want?
Would you rather… have a class pet or a class party every month?
Would you rather… have shorter school days but go to school year-round or have longer school days but have a longer summer break?

Arts & Creativity – Exploring Different Forms of Expression

Would you rather… be a famous singer or a famous artist?
Would you rather… write a book or illustrate a children’s book?
Would you rather… be able to sing beautifully or dance gracefully?
Would you rather… act in a play or create the sets and costumes for a play?
Would you rather… learn to play the guitar or the piano?
Would you rather… direct a movie or write a screenplay?
Would you rather… create a sculpture or paint a mural?
Would you rather… design clothes or build furniture?
Would you rather… write a song or a poem?
Would you rather… learn photography or filmmaking?
Would you rather… perform on stage in front of a large audience or create art in a quiet studio?
Would you rather… attend a concert or visit an art museum?

These “would you rather…” questions provide a balance of silly scenarios, challenging choices, and relatable topics, perfect for sparking conversation, laughter, and deeper thinking with elementary school-aged children. Remember to encourage them to explain their reasoning – you might be surprised by their insightful (and hilarious) answers. These questions also align with educational goals, helping children develop critical thinking, communication skills, and decision-making abilities while having fun.

C. Would You Rather Questions for Middle Schoolers (Ages 11-13)

Middle school is a time of navigating complex social landscapes, developing personal identities, and grappling with increasingly complex concepts. Tweens and young teenagers face unique challenges and exciting opportunities as they transition into adolescence. “Would you rather…” questions can be a valuable tool for sparking engaging conversations, encouraging critical thinking, and exploring these evolving perspectives with a touch of humor and a dash of social relevance. These thought-provoking dilemmas are perfect for classroom discussions, youth group activities, or simply hanging out with friends.

Social & Friendship Dilemmas:

Would you rather… have a lot of friends or one very close best friend?
Would you rather… be really popular or really smart?
Would you rather… fit in with the crowd or stand out and be unique?
Would you rather… have the power to read minds or know what people are really thinking about you?
Would you rather… tell your best friend a difficult truth or keep a secret to protect their feelings?
Would you rather… be known for your kindness or your sense of humor?
Would you rather… have the ability to make everyone like you or have the ability to always know when someone is lying?
Would you rather… be able to change your appearance at will or change your personality at will?
Would you rather… be the best student in your class or the most talented athlete?
Would you rather… have amazing artistic skills or incredible musical talent?
Would you rather… go to a school dance with someone you like but who isn’t popular or with someone popular who you don’t really like?
Would you rather… have a embarrassing moment go viral online or have your biggest secret revealed to your friends?

Technology & Trends – Expanding into Social Media, Online Interactions, and Digital Life:

Would you rather… have the coolest phone or the coolest shoes?
Would you rather… live without video games or without social media?
Would you rather… be a famous YouTuber or a successful app developer?
Would you rather… have unlimited data or a phone that never dies?
Would you rather… only be able to text or only be able to talk on the phone?
Would you rather… have all the latest gadgets or have incredible experiences?
Would you rather… be an influencer with millions of followers or have a small group of very close friends online?
Would you rather… be able to communicate telepathically or teleport anywhere instantly?
Would you rather… live in a world with advanced technology or a simpler world without technology?
Would you rather… have a robot do your chores or have a personal chef cook all your meals?
Would you rather… lose all your social media accounts or lose all your photos and videos?
Would you rather… live in a virtual reality world or the real world?

Abilities & Skills – Focusing on Personal Talents, Strengths, and Aspirations

Would you rather… be able to read minds or teleport?
Would you rather… speak any language in the world or play any musical instrument perfectly?
Would you rather… be incredibly athletic or incredibly artistic?
Would you rather… have photographic memory or be able to predict the future?
Would you rather… be super strong or super smart?
Would you rather… be able to fly or breathe underwater?
Would you rather… have super speed or the ability to freeze time?
Would you rather… be invisible or be able to shapeshift into any animal?
Would you rather… have the ability to heal others or have the ability to control the weather?
Would you rather… be a master of disguise or a skilled hacker?
Would you rather… be a talented writer or a gifted public speaker?
Would you rather… be a skilled athlete or a brilliant scientist?

School & Future – Focusing on Academic Choices, Career Paths, and Life Goals

Would you rather… get perfect grades without studying or be naturally talented at any sport?
Would you rather… go to your dream college or start your own successful business?
Would you rather… travel the world or have a job you love?
Would you rather… have a guaranteed future success or the freedom to pursue your passions, even if it’s risky?
Would you rather… know your future career path or have unlimited options to explore?
Would you rather… go to college immediately after high school or take a gap year to travel or work?
Would you rather… have a high-paying job you don’t enjoy or a low-paying job you love?
Would you rather… live a comfortable life or an adventurous life?
Would you rather… work alone or work as part of a team?
Would you rather… be a leader or a follower?
Would you rather… make a lot of money or make a difference in the world?
Would you rather… have a stable job or start your own business?

Personal Interests – Focusing on Hobbies, Entertainment, and Pop Culture:

Would you rather… spend a day binge-watching your favorite TV series or reading a captivating book?
Would you rather… go to a concert of your favorite band or meet a celebrity you admire?
Would you rather… have front-row seats to a sporting event or backstage passes to a music festival?
Would you rather… be a character in your favorite book or your favorite movie?
Would you rather… have the ability to learn any skill instantly or have any talent you desire?
Would you rather… meet your favorite fictional character or your favorite historical figure?
Would you rather… live in the world of your favorite video game or the world of your favorite book series?
Would you rather… have a superpower based on your favorite superhero or possess a magical item from your favorite fantasy story?
Would you rather… write fan fiction for your favorite fandom or create fan art for your favorite characters?
Would you rather… attend a comic convention or a gaming tournament?
Would you rather… have your own personalized merchandise of your favorite things or have an unlimited supply of your favorite snacks and drinks?
Would you rather… meet the creators of your favorite content or collaborate with them on a project?

These diverse questions offer a mix of lighthearted fun and opportunities for deeper discussion, making them perfect for engaging middle schoolers in thoughtful conversations and helping them navigate the complexities of their world. Encourage them to explain their choices and consider the potential consequences of each scenario, which further enhances their critical thinking and decision-making skills. They are also designed to be relevant to current trends and interests, appealing to a broad audience of middle school students.

D. Would You Rather Questions for High Schoolers (Ages 14-18)

High school is a period of significant transitions, big decisions, and the development of personal values. “Would you rather…” questions can be a surprisingly effective tool for exploring complex themes, encouraging self-reflection, and sparking meaningful conversations amongst older teens and young adults. These questions delve into future aspirations, ethical dilemmas, and the personal values that will shape their future decisions. These conversation starters are ideal for classroom discussions, debate clubs, youth groups, or simply hanging out with friends.

Future & Career:

Would you rather… travel the world or have a successful and stable career?
Would you rather… have a job you love that pays little or a job you dislike that pays extremely well?
Would you rather… live in a big city with lots of opportunities or a small town with a close-knit community?
Would you rather… be famous and admired or make a significant positive impact on the world, even if it goes unnoticed?
Would you rather… go to your dream college or take a gap year to pursue a personal project?
Would you rather… be a CEO of a major corporation or start your own small business?
Would you rather… work a traditional 9-to-5 job or have a flexible, remote career?
Would you rather… prioritize work-life balance or career advancement?
Would you rather… be an entrepreneur or work for a non-profit organization?
Would you rather… have a job that requires a lot of travel or a job that allows you to work from home?
Would you rather… pursue a career in the arts or sciences?
Would you rather… be a teacher or a doctor?

Life Choices & Values – Expanding on Ethical Dilemmas and Personal Beliefs

Would you rather… find true love or achieve your biggest dream?
Would you rather… have unlimited wealth or perfect health?
Would you rather… have the power to change the past or see into the future?
Would you rather… be known for your intelligence or your kindness?
Would you rather… make decisions based on logic or your gut feeling?
Would you rather… always tell the truth, even if it hurts someone’s feelings, or tell a white lie to protect someone?
Would you rather… have the ability to make any wish come true but only for yourself, or make smaller wishes come true for others?
Would you rather… stand up for what you believe in, even if it’s unpopular, or go along with the crowd to avoid conflict?
Would you rather… have the power to save one person’s life or improve the lives of many people in a small way?
Would you rather… sacrifice your own happiness for the greater good or prioritize your own well-being?
Would you rather… live a life of comfort and security or a life of adventure and risk?
Would you rather… follow your dreams, even if they seem impossible, or choose a more practical path?

Social Issues & Global Perspectives – Adding Specificity and Relevance to Current Events:

Would you rather… live in a world without poverty or a world without war?
Would you rather… solve climate change or find a cure for all diseases?
Would you rather… have the power to influence political decisions or the ability to inspire social change through art?
Would you rather… focus on making a difference locally or globally?
Would you rather… live in a world with complete equality or a world with absolute freedom?
Would you rather… address issues of income inequality or focus on improving access to education?
Would you rather… promote sustainable living or advocate for animal rights?
Would you rather… work to combat discrimination or promote peace and understanding between different cultures?
Would you rather… focus on improving healthcare access or addressing homelessness and food insecurity?
Would you rather… fight for freedom of speech or the right to privacy?
Would you rather… dedicate your life to scientific research or humanitarian aid?
Would you rather… focus on national issues or international relations?

Hypothetical & Philosophical Ponderings:

Would you rather… live in the past or the future?
Would you rather… have superpowers or be incredibly wealthy?
Would you rather… know everything or be able to forget anything?
Would you rather… live a short but incredibly fulfilling life or a long but average life?
Would you rather… have the ability to time travel or the ability to read minds?
Would you rather… have the answer to every question or the ability to ask the perfect question?
Would you rather… be able to relive your best memories or erase your worst memories?
Would you rather… live in a perfect utopia or a challenging but real world?
Would you rather… have free will or live in a predetermined destiny?
Would you rather… understand the meaning of life or experience everything life has to offer?
Would you rather… never feel pain or never feel sadness?
Would you rather… be able to control your dreams or be able to remember all your dreams perfectly?

Relationships & Social Dynamics – Exploring Dating, Friendships, Family, and Communication:

Would you rather… date someone popular but shallow or someone kind and genuine but not popular?
Would you rather… have a large group of acquaintances or a small circle of close friends?
Would you rather… have your parents be strict but loving or lenient but less involved in your life?
Would you rather… be able to resolve any conflict peacefully or always win an argument?
Would you rather… be completely independent or rely on others for support and guidance?
Would you rather… express your emotions openly and honestly or keep your feelings private?
Would you rather… forgive someone who has wronged you or hold onto resentment?
Would you rather… be able to tell if someone is lying or be able to convince anyone of anything?
Would you rather… have the perfect romantic relationship or the perfect family relationship?
Would you rather… have the power to mend broken relationships or the ability to prevent relationships from ending?
Would you rather… be a social butterfly or a quiet observer?
Would you rather… easily make new friends or maintain long-lasting friendships?

These “would you rather…” questions provide high school students with a chance to engage with complex ideas and consider different perspectives. Encourage open discussions and deeper reflection on the reasons behind their choices. This can be a valuable exercise in critical thinking and exploring the values that will shape their future decisions. The questions also address a wider range of topics relevant to teenagers’ lives, including relationships, social dynamics, and personal interests, reflecting a comprehensive understanding of the high school experience and the challenges and opportunities it presents.

Tips for Playing “Would You Rather” with Kids and Students

“Would You Rather…?” is more than just a children’s game; it’s a versatile educational tool that can be adapted for various ages, learning objectives, and social situations. Whether you’re a parent, teacher, or caregiver, these tips will help you make the most of this engaging activity:

A. Adapting for Different Ages & Developmental Stages

Choosing age-appropriate questions is crucial for a successful game of “Would You Rather…?”.

Preschool (3-5 years): Early childhood is a time of rapid development. Focus on concrete, easily understood choices related to their everyday experiences, like food preferences (“Would you rather… eat an apple or a banana?”), favorite activities (“Would you rather… play with blocks or play dress-up?”), and familiar characters (“Would you rather… meet Elmo or Big Bird?”). This helps develop their basic vocabulary and decision-making skills. Consider questions involving sensory experiences: “Would you rather… play with something soft or something rough?”
Elementary School (6-10 years): As children enter elementary school, introduce more imaginative scenarios and silly dilemmas while still keeping the choices relatively simple. Explore themes of fantasy (“Would you rather… have the ability to fly or be invisible?”), animals (“Would you rather… have a pet dog or a pet cat?”), and everyday fun (“Would you rather… go to the beach or the amusement park?”). Encourage them to start explaining their reasoning to foster early critical thinking.
Middle School (11-13 years): Tweens can handle more complex and nuanced questions that touch on social dynamics, emerging values, and hypothetical situations. Explore themes of friendship (“Would you rather… have many friends or a few close ones?”), technology (“Would you rather… live without your phone or the internet?”), and future aspirations (“Would you rather… be famous or wealthy?”). These questions can spark important conversations about social-emotional learning and responsible decision-making.
High School (14-18 years): Engage teenagers with thought-provoking questions that delve into ethical dilemmas, future planning, and abstract concepts. Consider questions about social issues (“Would you rather… live in a world without poverty or a world without war?”), philosophical concepts (“Would you rather… have the ability to change the past or see the future?”), and career paths (“Would you rather… pursue your passion or a stable, high-paying job?”). This helps them develop advanced critical thinking skills and explore their personal values.

B. Making it Educational

“Would you rather…” isn’t just for fun; it can be a powerful educational activity.

Vocabulary Building: Expand vocabulary by intentionally incorporating new words into the question choices. For younger children, provide definitions or context clues. “Would you rather… have something minuscule or something enormous?” is a great example.
Critical Thinking & Decision-Making: Always ask “why?” after a child makes a choice. This encourages them to articulate their reasoning, developing valuable critical thinking and decision-making skills.
Debate & Communication Skills: Structure the game as a friendly debate, having students defend their choices and respectfully challenge opposing viewpoints. This fosters communication skills and respectful disagreement.
Curriculum Integration: Align questions with specific curriculum topics for a more targeted learning experience. In history, ask, “Would you rather… live in ancient Rome or ancient Egypt?”. In science, try “Would you rather… explore the Amazon rainforest or the depths of the ocean?”.

C. Handling Difficult Situations

Establish clear ground rules before the game begins. Emphasize that “Would You Rather…?” is a hypothetical game, and choices shouldn’t be taken personally.

Disagreements: If a question leads to disagreement, model respectful communication and help children find common ground or agree to disagree.
Sensitive Topics: Steer clear of potentially embarrassing or sensitive personal information. Be mindful of the emotional maturity of the group.
Inappropriate Questions: If a child proposes an inappropriate question, gently explain why it’s not suitable for the game and redirect their focus.

D. Variations on the Game

Keep the game fresh and exciting with these variations:

“This or That”: A simplified version ideal for younger children.
“Most Likely To”: A fun and engaging variation for older kids and teens to explore personality traits and social dynamics within a group.
“Would You Rather… BUT…”: Introduce consequences to add a new layer of complexity and challenge to decision-making. “Would you rather… have the ability to fly BUT be afraid of heights, or be able to breathe underwater BUT be allergic to seafood?” is a great example. Consider more examples like: “Would you rather… have unlimited money BUT have no friends, or have a few close friends BUT no money?” or “Would you rather… be able to eat anything you want BUT never taste it, or only be able to eat healthy food BUT savor every bite?”

By following these tips and adapting the game to suit your specific audience and goals, you can transform “Would You Rather…?” into a versatile and engaging activity that promotes learning, encourages communication, and provides hours of fun for kids and students of all ages. It’s a valuable tool for parents, educators, and anyone working with children and teens. And if screen-free fun is your goal, don’t forget to explore our other great resources on engaging family card games, card games for kids and exciting dice games for kids of all ages – perfect for family game nights, classroom activities, or rainy day entertainment!

Guessing & Mystery Games